Add to Technorati Favorites

BrandlandUSA

The Deal

The Tan Sheet

advertising age

Allegra OTC

Search

Testimonials

Banner

Online Affiliations

Over the Counter Today

Health

Top Blogs

Blog Directory for USA

Share Our Site

Support us today by putting a link to our site on your blog or personal website. Click Here to find out how.

November 20, 2009: Hand Sanitizers (updated) PDF Print E-mail

GERM – X with ALOE [12oz PUMP]

Link to site ►
  • $0.17/oz*
  • Inexpensive, standard ethyl alcohol formula with isopropanol
  • Very slight residual tackiness, pleasant aloe smell

GERM-X ADVANCED PROTECTION [7oz FOAM PUMP]

Link to site ►
  • $0.35/oz* [+ 100% Germ-X with Aloe]
  • Alcohol-free formula in aqueous foam
  • More reliable active ingredient [benzalkonium 0.13%]
  • No residual tackiness, vaguely grape odor

PURELL with ALOE [8oz PUMP]

Link to site ►
  • $0.37/oz* [+ 118% Germ-X with Aloe]
  • Pricey, branded version of Germ-X with Aloe
  • Very slight residual tackiness, pleasant smell

GOLD BOND ULTIMATE HAND SANITIZER MOISTURIZER [2.7oz Tube]

Link to site ►
Updated Item
  • Very expensive compared to alcohol sanitizers [$1.47/oz, 8.6x Germ-X*]
  • First hand moisturizer with antimicrobial claim on skin lotion shelf
  • Unlikely to attract male buyers unlike alcohol based products
  • Complex, no-alcohol formula leaves residue behind
  • Off-putting chemical odor on application
  • Paper peel-off label stuck onto plastic tube cheapens look

* = Walmart pricing, 12/24/09


Alcohol-Based Hand Sanitizers

Product Benefits

  • The most visible of products
  • Good protection from transmitting GI viruses on hands
  • Cheap protection against virus transmission by physical contact
  • Small portable sizes
  • Good step in buying some insurance against various illness

Product Watch Outs

  • Leaves slight tacky residue
  • 60-70% (ethyl) alcohol is not predictably effective against all microbes
  • Not effective against flu or colds viruses when transmitted by aerosol, sneezing, coughing

Price/Value

  • Ingredients are cheap commodities; formulae simple
  • Stick to cheapest product or store brand
  • Avoid expensive brands or crèmes
  • More sophisticated formulae are still unapproved

Consider the Alternatives

  • Handwashing, particularly with triclosan containing soaps [Safeguard, Equate]
  • Alcohol-free benzalkonium containing products [e.g.- Germ-X Advanced Protection]

Comments (0)

Write comment

smaller | bigger

busy
 

website by 7 Weight Designs